What Actually Causes Bloating? The Science Behind Your Uncomfortable Stomach

Bloating is one of the most common digestive complaints worldwide. Up to 30% of adults report experiencing it regularly, and among people with IBS, that number climbs to 90%.¹ Yet despite how universal it is, most people have a surprisingly poor understanding of what actually causes it.

The reality is more complex — and more actionable — than “you ate too much.”

It’s not always about gas

The default assumption is that bloating means excess gas. Sometimes that’s true. But research has shown that many people who feel severely bloated don’t actually have more gas than normal.

Azpiroz and Malagelada studied gas dynamics in IBS patients and found that symptom severity often correlated poorly with the actual volume of intestinal gas. Some patients with severe bloating had normal gas volumes, while others with high gas volumes felt fine.²

What differs is how the body perceives and handles that gas. This concept — visceral hypersensitivity — turns out to be central to understanding bloating.

Visceral hypersensitivity: your gut’s volume knob

Visceral hypersensitivity means your gut nerves overreact to normal stimuli. A volume of gas that one person wouldn’t notice can feel painful and distending to someone with heightened gut nerve sensitivity.

Simrén et al. demonstrated this using balloon distension tests in IBS patients. Patients with bloating showed significantly lower thresholds for discomfort compared to healthy controls — their guts were literally more sensitive to the same amount of pressure.³

This explains a frustrating pattern many people experience: eating the exact same meal as someone else and being the only one who ends up bloated. The food isn’t the only variable — your nervous system’s response matters just as much.

FODMAP fermentation: the gas factory

When bloating is related to gas production, the mechanism is usually fermentation. Your large intestine is home to trillions of bacteria, and when certain carbohydrates reach them undigested, those bacteria ferment them and produce gas — primarily hydrogen and methane.

FODMAPs (fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides, and polyols) are the carbohydrates most commonly responsible. They’re poorly absorbed in the small intestine and arrive in the colon largely intact, where bacteria feast on them.

Ong et al. measured hydrogen and methane production in IBS patients after high-FODMAP versus low-FODMAP meals. High-FODMAP meals produced significantly more hydrogen gas in both IBS patients and healthy controls — but only the IBS patients reported increased symptoms.⁴

This is a critical finding: the gas production was similar in both groups, but the symptom response was dramatically different. It circles back to visceral hypersensitivity — the combination of normal fermentation plus heightened sensitivity creates the bloating experience.

The motility factor

How quickly food moves through your digestive tract also affects bloating. Slower transit means more time for fermentation, and it means gas accumulates rather than passing through.

Agrawal et al. used CT scanning to show that patients with bloating often had impaired gas transit — gas pooled in certain segments of the intestine rather than moving through efficiently. In some cases, the diaphragm descended and the abdominal wall relaxed paradoxically, creating visible distension.⁵

This motility component explains why bloating often worsens throughout the day and improves overnight — gravity and posture affect gas distribution, and lying down allows gas to redistribute more evenly.

The microbiome connection

Your individual gut bacteria composition directly influences how much gas specific foods produce. Two people eating the same bowl of lentils will ferment them differently based on their unique microbial profiles.

Tap et al. analyzed the gut microbiomes of over 300 IBS patients and found that specific bacterial signatures correlated with bloating severity. Patients with more severe bloating had distinct microbial profiles, including reduced bacterial diversity and altered ratios of gas-producing versus gas-consuming species.⁶

This explains why food triggers are so individual. Your microbiome is as unique as your fingerprint, which means your fermentation response to any given food is unique too.

SIBO: when bacteria are in the wrong place

Small intestinal bacterial overgrowth (SIBO) occurs when excessive bacteria colonize the small intestine, where they don’t belong in large numbers. This causes fermentation to happen earlier in the digestive process, producing gas in a location that’s not equipped to handle it.

Pimentel et al. found that a significant proportion of IBS patients with bloating tested positive for SIBO using breath testing. Treatment with targeted antibiotics reduced both bacterial overgrowth and bloating symptoms.⁷

SIBO isn’t the explanation for all bloating, but it’s worth investigating if bloating is persistent, occurs shortly after eating (within 30-60 minutes), and doesn’t respond to dietary changes alone.

What actually helps

Based on the research, effective bloating management targets the specific mechanism involved:

For fermentation-related bloating:

• A low-FODMAP elimination diet identifies which specific fermentable carbohydrates trigger your symptoms⁸
• Most people only need to restrict 2-4 specific triggers long-term, not all FODMAPs permanently

For motility-related bloating:

• Physical activity improves gas transit — even a short walk after meals helps⁹
• Peppermint oil has evidence for reducing bloating through smooth muscle relaxation

For sensitivity-related bloating:

• Gut-directed hypnotherapy has strong evidence for reducing visceral hypersensitivity¹⁰
• Stress management reduces the amplification of gut sensations (stress literally turns up the volume on gut nerve signaling)

For all types:

• Eating slowly and chewing thoroughly reduces air swallowing
• Tracking meals and symptoms identifies your personal pattern

The bottom line

Bloating isn’t one condition with one cause. It’s the end result of multiple possible mechanisms — excess fermentation, impaired gas transit, visceral hypersensitivity, altered microbiome composition, or some combination of these.

The practical implication: generic advice like “avoid dairy” or “take probiotics” works for some people and fails for others, because it doesn’t account for which mechanism is driving your bloating. The most effective approach is systematic tracking and elimination to identify your individual triggers and patterns.

References